On Mon, 15 Nov 2004 11:15:34 -0500, Carl Hutzler wrote:
? Only reason we are testing the SPF record against the HELO is for
? a test. We do not know one way or another if this is a good idea
? to implement on a wider scale or not. It is usually better to have
? different DNS statements/configs for different things and HELO is
? very different from an email domain in the 822 or 821 mailfrom
? headers. So my engineering background would say it is better to
? have separate ones.
? But since no one is publishing CSV records yet (including
? me....bad me), we have to start somewhere.
Thanks for the followup. Let me make the request more clear. It was not meant
as a challenge; indeed your ready willingness to try anything that folks think
might be useful -- no matter how crazy some of us might think it -- is pretty
The request is for the technical details of what exactly you will look for and
what semantic you will apply. In other words, the request is for something
like a specification, rather than a rationale.
dcrocker ?a t ...