Apparently you expect the extensive, open group consensus process that
was pursued TWICE on this matter to have no import, but the last-minute,
vague whim of a few posters instead should hold sway.
Unless you can cite an IETF BCP RFC that authorizes unchartered,
self-appointed, ad hoc groups to dictate the terms of their charters,
constrain the behavior of chartered IETF working groups, or overrule the
decisions of IESG in chartering a group, please rest your case.
Ietf mailing list