Your email landed in my spam folder due to lacking a References: header.
Please consider doing us the courtesy of using a mail client which
conforms to RFC2822 and keeps threads together.
On Mon, 2005-01-10 at 05:38 -0800, Hallam-Baker, Phillip wrote:
You didn't seem to think MARID was the proper place to discuss SPF.
I don't recall expressing that opinion. I thought that MARID _was_ the
proper place to discuss SPF.
As for the 'insurmountable problems' with SPF I have never once seen the CSV
faction manage to give a coherent explanation (note this is NOT an
invitation for another attempt). If the problems do exist then they must
either be fixable or affect CSV equally.
CSV does not attempt to restrict MAIL FROM addresses to a limited set of
IP addresses; thus it does not share the same fundamentally flawed
assumptions as SPF.