ietf-mxcomp
[Top] [All Lists]

Problematic issues with regard to last call

2004-08-27 03:44:42

MARID participants,

There have been a few problematic statements during this last call period that need to be addressed.

First, some of the issues raised are premised on the issue of scope... as in Sender ID does not do X when X is not something Sender ID ever intended to do. That whole argument could be applied to any MARID output and even to the MARID charter itself. While such opinions are valid and in most cases factual, they are misplaced at this time.

Second, there have been a few messages soliciting polls and requesting adjusted timelines. We ask that participants refrain from deviating the working group from its last call period. While you may feel passionate about a certain issue, please be considerate of the process. The co-chairs are interested in reading thoughtful opinions and not just raised hands or parroted thought. Additionally, timelines have been set to accommodate individuals who may not be available at this week due to vacation, travel, or numerous other reasonable absences from an Internet connection.

Finally, some participants have outright stated that they are interested only in the advancement of a competing specification to Sender ID while others have not said so much but have taken a similar tone. This is most offensive and counter to the notion of finding a consensus-based standard. Many individuals in this working group have worked very hard to find common ground, and this unilateralism is unfair to them. If it is your intent to be unwavering and steadfast in your opinion no matter the discourse of the issues, we ask that you disengage from this working group.

-andy