I further agree with Phillip (and Richard) that this is not an IAB
or even a Nomcom chair decision
I disagree. The chair of a committee should have some freedom to
decide what to do in cases not covered by the RFC. The
decision he made (rerun the algorithm with correct input data) is
a reasonable one by any standard. Let's just accept his decision
and go on with our work.
I second that!
Ietf mailing list