Dave Crocker wrote:
Yes, but how does (or should) your comment affect the draft charter text?
S Moonesamy wrote:
I'll quote from
http://www.ietf.org/mail-archive/web/ietf-announce/current/msg13031.html
"Existing deployment of DMARC has demonstrated utility at internet
scale"
I would propose to adjust this statement to better match reality.
"Existing deployment of DMARC has demonstrated moderate success
for some providers and some parts of the internet, and at the
same time interferes fatally with mailing list usage of
DMARC-affected EMail user accounts and mail forwarding.
But the by far most serious problem is that processing of EMail
according to DMARC by a telecommunicatios service provider
is a real and serious criminal offense in countries with strong
protections of fundamental human rights, such as many member
countries of the European Union, and this precludes that
DMARC could ever scale to the entire internet.
-Martin