ietf-822
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: Motif Compound Strings

1991-06-25 09:28:22
I would suggest that any text formatting be handled similar to
X-window Motif strings, which are a C-type XmString.

I strongly oppose this concept.  It reeks of a proprietary bias (towards
both OSF & Motif) and is not a technical solution that we can use now
and expect people to read despite older mailers (as Erik noted above).

The richtext solution seems vastly preferable.

Thank you Ran, I've been trying to figure out how to formulate a 
response that expresses the above thought without being rude.

Folks, the Internet is not U**X, U**X isn't OSF, and even OSF is not 
Motif and X.  This is not a plausible solution for the very large number 
of older and/or smaller and/or cheaper machines that operate as Internet 
hosts.  Models such as richtext are closely related to established (and 
widely-supported) International Standards such as SGML), can be
supported in several different ways in a variety of different machine
types, and are plausibly readable on hosts that don't know that they are 
different from ASCII.  Seems to me that those are *very* powerful 
advantages compared to a form that is mostly extremely convenient on 
hosts that, almost by definition, have the surplus horsepower lying 
around to convert rapidly from more abstract and generic formats.

  --john

<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>