ietf-822
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: empty quoted strings and other oddities

2002-10-07 09:57:24


In <p0510031db9c2ed7c528f(_at_)[130(_dot_)237(_dot_)161(_dot_)114]> Jacob 
Palme <jpalme(_at_)dsv(_dot_)su(_dot_)se> writes:

In early mail systems, it was allowed to specify a
recipient address with only the local name. This would
then default to the sender's domain. Thus,

From: John(_at_)duckville(_dot_)org
To: Mary

would default to

From: John(_at_)duckville(_dot_)org
To: Mary(_at_)duckville(_dot_)org

This is not allowed any more, but some local UA-MTA
might still allow this technique.

Are you sure this is not allowed? My local UA-MTA (dtmail-sendmail)
certainly allows if, and sendmail.cf automatically cleans it up before
letting it be seen in the outside world.

Do not confuse the myriad illegal formats allowed and fixed up by sendmail
(or most any other MTA for that matter) with 

The incomplete form never gets seen on any "wire". So is any standard
violated in that case?

There's considerable value in having a standardized submission protocol in
addition to having a standardized transfer protocol. RFC 2476 provided the
first step along this path.

                                Ned