ietf-822
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: Dual names, IDN and ASCII, in e-mail addresses?

2003-10-08 16:12:07

Bruce Lilly writes:
Also, I see no reason why some text sequence in different languages should not encode to different DNS names, just as "boot" in German and "boot" in English refer to two very different things (indeed, there are differences between en-us and en-uk) -- in fact it seems highly desirable that they *should* encode to different DNS names.

If "www.josé.com" resolves to different domains depending on the viewer's locale, the phishers and scammers will have a grand time registering domains that look like the their victims' domains somewhere in the world and then swindling the users in that part of the world.

If "www.josé.com" isn't usable, because it always has to look like e.g. "www.josé(es).com" or "www.josé(pt_BR).com", I predict that few businesses will bother with the whole thing. (Well. I suppose some Turkmen might like having "www.josé(tm).com".)

--Arnt