ietf-smime
[Top] [All Lists]

RE: S/MIME ECC Doc

2001-04-25 04:41:26
Hi Russ,

Thanks for the speedy response.

I have no problem with this.  Can we add a paragraph to the Security
Considerations that warns implementors that a wider has MAY be specified
when stronger (symmetric algorithms with longer key sizes) are supported
(e.g., AES)?

Okay.

Please add a Intellectual Property Rights section to the document.  Please
take a look a section 9 of RFC 2459 for an example.  Also, take a look at
the references made in the discussion of the RSA algorithm (the patent had
not expired when RFC 2459 was published).  This provides a simple "heads up."

I think we already have an IPR section in the document. Rather than single out
one algorithm for an IPR pointer, we propose to add a sentence to the abstract
along the similar lines to 2459 - something like "An IPR statement regarding the
use of ECC in CMS can be found in Section xyz". Okay?

Best regards. Simon




<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>