Ok, the additional discussion on this text has indicated that John
should leave the text in, as per his preference, with the possible
addition of Mark's "FTP's" text.
This issue is closed.
Tony Hansen
tony(_at_)att(_dot_)com
John C Klensin wrote:
--On Sunday, 29 April, 2007 23:04 -0400 Tony Hansen
<tony(_at_)att(_dot_)com> wrote:
The consensus on this text
It is worth noting that the file transfer protocol (FTP
[35]) uses a very similar code architecture and that the
SMTP codes are based on the FTP model. However, SMTP uses a
one-command, one-response model, while FTP is asynchronous
and the 1yz codes are not part of the SMTP model.
is almost dead even. I'll leave this one open for two more
days, then give a consensus call. If it remains even, it will
become "editor's choice".
Speaking personally (not as editor), I'm slightly inclined to
leave it, simply because dropping of the 1yz text would seem odd
without _some_ comment. Very slightly, however.
john