Re: [secdir] [New-work] WG Review: New IETF Standards Track (newtrk)

One item in the proposed charter concerns me greatly:


  The working group should also take into account other issues raised by the
  problem working group and during the newtrk BOF as needed.

That does not sound narrowly scoped at all.  It might be reasonable to
take into account these items as they relate to the explicitly
enumerated goals of the working group, but it does not seem reasonable
to take into account issues that would create a new goal or expand the
scope of the working group.

--Sam