ietf
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: [secdir] secdir review of draft-ietf-emu-chbind-14

2012-04-23 19:56:59

First, Steve, thanks for an excellent review.
You detected some really important fixes we need to make!

Hi.  I'll respond in more detail later.  I generally agree with Joe's
comments.
I want to respond to the IANA issues so Joe doesn't have to dig around.

Early allocation is a well-defined concept; I forgot to reference the
appropriate RFC, but IANA does (and according to their last call
comments did in this case) understand it.

IANA also correctly assumed the codes registry is a sub-registry not a
new top-level registry.

I don't mind fixing, but I'll point out that IANA was not actually
confused nor did they request clarification.