fetchmail-friends
[Top] [All Lists]

[fetchmail] Comcast.net message truncation

2003-07-30 16:06:25
With the recent move of some POP3 services from attbi.com to comcast.net,
I started to notice truncation of messages at just under 80 KB for email
accounts hosted at comcast.  I ran a bunch of experiments before/after
finding a FAQ item about the problem:

        http://catb.org/~esr/fetchmail/fetchmail-FAQ.html#I8 

The problem appears to be caused by a bug/limitation in Comcast's
Maillennium POP3/PROXY server implementation of the TOP command
and not an overall limitation on message size like the FAQ implies.
POP3 clients such as MS OE 6.0 see no message truncation because they
use RETR instead of TOP.

Adding the "fetchall" keyword to the fetchmailrc entries for comcast.net
servers solves the problem by forcing fetchmail to use RETR instead
of TOP:

        Bad:
                poll mail.comcast.net proto pop3
                        user "me" pass "secret" is "me" here

        Good:
                poll mail.comcast.net proto pop3
                        user "me" pass "secret" is "me" here fetchall

This should be added to the FAQ as an acceptable work-around.

Seth
seth(_at_)zirin(_dot_)net

<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>