ietf-822
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: multipart clarification/nits

1994-11-04 13:47:04
If a 
delimiter is allowed to have an arbitrary amount of whitespace 
between the boundary and the CRLF, then a parser must have an 
arbitrary amount of lookahead in order to determine whether a 
line is a delimiter or not. 
 
        Not quite. 
 
It isn't allowed to have this. I hope this is clearer now. 
 
        [sigh]   I wish you hadn't said that. 
 
        Actually,  it's probably better that the spec be  "too tight" 
than that it be too broad.   I was about to say,  "white space processing 
in boundary scanning doesn't have to be such a nightmare",  but then I 
brought more neurons to bear on what's happening.   We're trying to 
force binary through that-which-was a text mode service.   Right? 
 
        If that's correct,  then use Base64.   Did the light go on? 
(am I even on the right list?  Marilyn told me this morning not to 
talk before having my coffee)   I think the case was brought forth 
where Base64 isn't an option.   Fine.   Then just don't call it MIME 
in that case. 
 
        [now back to reading Crocker and Borenstein & Freed 
before I run my mouth any more] 
 
-- 
Rick Troth <troth(_at_)rice(_dot_)edu>, Rice University, Information Systems 
(grieving for Michael Daniel Smith and Alexander Tyler Smith) 


<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>