ietf-822
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: Is 8BIT ESTMP really needed

2001-05-10 17:12:01
ned(_dot_)freed(_at_)mrochek(_dot_)com writes:

Thus far in this conversation we have one anecdotal report that
there may be some systems that botch this, and which may well refer
to some long-vanished implementation from the early days of MIME.

Link to one discussion mentions MUAs but not MTAs:

http://www.gnus.org/list-archives/ding/199907/msg00657.html

I don't know if it really was a MUA issue.

According to the discussion it was a issue with Netscape on Windows. But this
is easily verified. I mailed a ~1Mb PDF with embedded color pictures and such
using quoted-printable. I also peeked at the content -- nasty! I then read it
using Netscape 4.77 on a Windows 98 system. It worked fine.

For good measure I tried it using Netscape 4.76 on Mac and Outlook Express 5.02
on Mac. They worked flawlessly as well. I would have tried it with Outlook on
Windows too but I could not figure out how to easily redirect it to a different
mail account.

So either the report was wrong in its particulars or else it is a problem that
has since been fixed. Regardless, the bottom line is that I cannot substantiate
the claim that this is actually a problem.

                                Ned