I have been reading the posts from this group for about the last week. I
have been deciding if I should post my thoughts on the 'GIEIS' architecture.
As a network engineer for one of Britian's larger Internet services, I view
'GIEIS' as being an acceptable solution. I have examined the site almost 20
times and even put the architecture to the test using paper and pen. I am
sorry to say that I could not find any point of weakness. I would have
enjoyed proving Mr McCarron wrong.
I think everyone on this list should carefully consider what Mr McCarron is
proposing. I understand the point about Mr McCarron being annoying and
posting frequently on the matter. On the other hand, 'GIEIS' is only what I
can describe as being a perfect architecture. It is funny the contrast
between the creator and the architecture.
The creation of almost 2 million jobs is a major selling point behind
'GIEIS'. I will admit it is marketing but Mr McCarron's figures do match
up. The ISP I work for is seriously considering investing in the
implementation program of 'GIEIS'. Not only does it make excellent business
sense to do so, but it also generates an unbelievable PR opportunity. Since
the release of version 0.003 of the 'GIEIS' proposal, high level meetings
have occured to discuss the system. When a new version appears, anyone
would be lead to believe that the CEO has arrived there are that many
managers present.
'GIEIS' is the simply one of the best proposals we have ever encountered.
All I would suggest is that you do not attempt to judge the system based
upon its creator.
Brian.
_________________________________________________________________
Get Hotmail on your mobile phone http://www.msn.co.uk/msnmobile
_______________________________________________
Asrg mailing list
Asrg(_at_)ietf(_dot_)org
https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/asrg