ietf-mxcomp
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: Draft submitted for Client Address Authorization.

2004-05-14 19:32:21

On 5/14/2004 4:32 PM, Douglas Otis sent forth electrons to convey:

Here is an early link to a draft submitted to the IETF utilizing the DNS
SRV record to publish authorized clients for any protocol including
SMTP.  This draft also suggests the label for this SRV record can be
used to access a TXT record for error reporting information.  This was
to provide a foundation for a solution independent of how the
information is used.  This takes advantage of existing DNS listing and
reporting features while not creating a record possibly confused as
pointing to an SMTP server.
http://www.mail-abuse.com/public/draft-dougotis-SRV-CAA-00.txt

Our name server was modified recently so it may take some time to access
to this link.  If so, try-

http://204.152.185.196/public/draft-dougotis-SRV-CAA-00.txt


-Doug

Interesting.

In other words,
something like
"dig _smtp._tcp_c.example.com SRV"
is done by an SMTP server receiving email from a client.

It's not defined where "example.com" came from. (derived fom return path, HELO, rDNS...)

It perhaps returns something like
...
;; ANSWER SECTION:
example.com. 3600 IN SRV fred.example.com. example.com. 3600 IN SRV sam.example.com.
;; AUTHORITY SECTION:
fred.example.com.              3600    IN      A      172.30.79.11
sam.example.com.              3600    IN      A      172.30.79.12
...
?
And if the client's IP is listed, then it is authorized by the domain administrator to send email. A domain with a large number of ns and mail servers might be in trouble, no? Say 8 RR's are returned, each of which reasolves to 8 A records (this is about the max in 512B packets) So the domain can have at most ~64 mail servers. Or am I missing something?

FYI, ZoneEdit (who does DNS for my domin and many others) doesn't support SRV, though they do support TXT.


<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>