ietf-mxcomp
[Top] [All Lists]

RE: [RFC 1464?] RE: Alternative to TXT or new RR was: Comments ondraft-ietf-marid-core-01 xml use

2004-06-13 09:56:06


I wrote:
The bottom line is that RFC 1464 was a syntax proposal design to 
simplify information sharing. A registry was proposed to control name 
collisions, but that never happened. It still seems to be a reasonable 
approach and perhaps someone will put it back on the standards track 
someday if appropriate.

Apologies for the ambiguity of my message. I meant to say that I thought the
syntax part (the core of RFC 1464) was a reasonable idea. I agree with
Phillip that the creation of a registry requires more thought.

Preventing name collisions through use of careful identifier selection would
be a good idea, registry or not (especially with no registry).

Rich