ietf-mxcomp
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: Is the back door open?

2004-07-27 18:26:30


On Jul 27, 2004, at 9:05 PM, Douglas Otis wrote:
This jump to step 5 omits checks for From headers in the message.

Right.  My eyes missed the Resent-From.  Sorry.

The random-1(_at_)dup(_dot_)com could have been a local user, (it had the right
domain), but when relayed to a MTA with a list of valid users, the mail
was rejected as the local part 'random-1' was not valid. The MTA second
to last in the chain, then bounces the message.  This may allow
filtering, or if done by a backup MTA, the knowledgeable server is
expected to be out of service.

Why would the first MTA receiving for dup.com not just reject the message?

-andy