ietf-mxcomp
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: How is SPF different from RMX?

2004-07-29 11:07:45

Jim Fenton wrote:

The message isn't accepted until the DATA command is accepted, at the end of the message. While the receiving domain has to provide bandwidth to receive at least part of the message, it can still reject the message (and doesn't have to provide storage for it) any time before the "OK". It can, potentially, tear down the TCP connection after receiving the relevant headers if it wants.

Just splitting hairs here:

If the server simply tears down the connection, the client MTA will handle it the same as a 421 error, and resend the message (and resend it, and resend it... for three days). If you really want to reject a message after a 354 response, then you'll have to swallow the whole message and send a 55x code in response to the dot. Then you'll have to hope that the client MTA does the Right Thing when it receives a 55x at that point -- some don't.

<csg>