ietf-mxcomp
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: regarding the trademark for "Sender ID"

2004-09-22 15:23:16

Andrew Newton wrote in mxcomp:

to our knowledge, the IETF has not been given permission to
use either "SenderID" or "Sender ID" marks

It is our opinion that all MARID documents should no longer
reference the output of the MARID working group as "Sender
ID" or any other similar mark.  We believe the risk to the
ISOC and the IETF standards publishing process to be too
great.

Good idea, let's use SPF, it's widely accepted, and it has a
certain fun factor.
 
If there is a need to refer to a simple name covering this
work in IETF documents, we recommend "MARID".

You wrote this Tue, 21 Sep 2004 13:15:58 -0400.  Apparently
the area directors failed to inform the co-chairs about their
plans to close MARID.  They also failed to discuss this idea
with the WG as outlined in BCP 25 chapter 4.  What else went
wrong ?
                        Bye, Frank