ietf-openpgp
[Top] [All Lists]

RE: PROPOSED OPEN-PGP Charter

1997-08-22 21:45:58
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----

On Fri, 22 Aug 1997, A. Padgett Peterson P.E. Information Security wrote:

The OPEN-PGP Specification will have provisions for;
1. interoperability using cryptographic algorithms (asymmetric/symmetric 
   including key lengths) that are consider strong, open and unencumbered, 
   and other algorithms MAY be used

This is not very good English - the word "may" removes any meaning/force.

I read the MAY as a RFC style requirement.  And as such has a (slightly)
diffrent meaning to the english one.

3. Government and legislative policies from any country SHOULD not impact 
the specification

Word "SHOULD" makes it a null statement - has same effect as "MAY"

No the meaning is diffrencent.  The SHOULD suggests that it is possable
but only after we have thought about all the concequencers of this action.

- -- 
Please excuse my spelling as I suffer from agraphia see the url in my header. 
Never trust a country with more peaple then sheep.  ex-net.scum and proud
You Say To People "Throw Off Your Chains" And They Make New Chains For
Themselves? --Terry Pratchett

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: 2.6.3i
Charset: noconv

iQCVAwUBM/4xc6QK0ynCmdStAQF9ZAP/T4P0Ttdo3XrqBa5C6nfwuwYXNpL9QzDI
9UoRy4ehqI1vtFLL98Z8G3wtriQtCRXvZ/5MFU7i6iLEhqv1xQ7Mc6Cn2rIP1KxA
3LEd/cHv0fSSx+DU0ctEEjtEipUhYNlTABgtFn6AC/sKs3LKphYnsjQWfEIFTOMo
kEQzMcPWAcw=
=M6KG
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----


<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>