ietf-smime
[Top] [All Lists]

RE: New versions of the drafts

1997-10-23 13:39:56

The following are, to some degree, nitpicks, but here they are:

In the S/MIME Message Specification draft:

1. In Section 3.1.4, unless there is something special that I don't
know, a CTE is required in the example for the image/jpeg.   Recommend:
Adding "Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64" to the example.

2.  In section 3.4.33 and section F2,  the application/pkcs7-signature
lines do not have an smime-type parameter.  I believe that this is
correct behavior, however it would appear from section E.2 that
smime-type is an optional parameter for this type.   I recommend that we
remove smime-type as an optional parameter in section E.2 and E.3.
(Failing that I believe that we need to specify a value(s) for it and
use it in our examples.)

Jim Schaad


<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>