ietf-smime
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: Comments on ESS-10

1999-01-14 08:43:27
Paul:

4.  Section 2.8 - ASN for Receipt still references Version not CMSVersion

Many thanks to Russ for switching this out from under me. :-) I do *not*
think we should import CMSVersion from CMS, because the version number we
are using here has nothing to do with CMS, and the name will be confusing.
Instead, I think I should define it as:

Version ::= INTEGER  { v1(1) }

Comments?

This change to CMS was made to avoid conflicts with the PKIX Part 1
definition of Version.

I agree that you should not import CMSVersion.  However, you should also
avoid the conflict with the PKIX Part 1 definition of Version.

I suggest that you use:

        ESSVersion ::= INTEGER  { v1(1) }

Russ

<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>