ietf-smime
[Top] [All Lists]

RE: WG Last Call: draft-ietf-smime-rfc3851bis-05.txt- from Sue

2008-09-09 10:28:47

Passing on some WG Last Call comments.

Russ

= = = = = = = = =

1) Section 1.6: Section 1.2 should be 1.3 (conventions section). Sec 1.3: Added references ... should be
Sect 1.4: Added references...

2) Inconsistency: DSA with SHA-256 is a MUST in Section 1.6 and SHOULD+ in section 2.2. 3250-bis and 3251-bis should be consistent for DSA with SHA-256.

3) section 1.6 mentions Sec 2.5.2.1 (there is no 2.5.2.1)

4) Section 1.6 referencing Sec 2.5.2: "DES-3EDE-CBC" and "AES-128 CBC" should be "DES-3EDE-CBC" with "AES-128 CBC"

5) Section 1.6 referencing Sec 7: update should be updated

6) I believe that Denis pointed this out already but there is a contradiction in key sizes for RSA signatures between 3850bis and 3851bis.

7) Error in reference [SMIMEv2] in both 3850bis and 3851bis; PKCS#7 is RFC 2315.

<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>