ietf
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: kernelizing the network resolver

2002-11-07 07:37:21


On Wed 2002.11.06, John Stracke wrote:

V Guruprasad wrote:

In short,
you continue to have the full socket API with no impediment to its use.

This is misleading.  You say that your main motivation here is to move
the identification role out of IP up to DNS, and moving the resolver
into the kernel is a necessary first step for that.  But it's not a
sufficient first step; to eliminate IP addresses as identifiers, you
have to remove the socket API.

No more than you need to disable the socket API for MAC layer or
ATM AAL5 access.


Since you can't strip the id role from names, it must be stripped from
IP, and that's what my thesis is about. ]


You can't strip the ID role from IP, either, unless you provide a new
form of ID for transport protocols to use.

Read my thesis.