ietf
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: Proposal to define a simple architecture to differentiate legitimate bulk email from Spam (UBE)

2003-09-07 15:29:55
Iljitsch van Beijnum <iljitsch(_at_)muada(_dot_)com> wrote:

On maandag, sep 8, 2003, at 00:08 Europe/Amsterdam, Johnny Eriksson 
wrote:

It is not immune to spam

Fixable with authentication.

no.

As each individual news article is piped through a relatively small 
number of servers in the "core" of the distribution system, it becomes 
relatively easy to blacklist known offenders. That is, if they are 
recognizable as such.

No way.  If this was indeed the case, it would already have been
handled by blacklisting known AS numbers / prefixes in the routing
system.  This is not the case.  See below.

                      This is where the authentication comes in.

This is where layer eight and above comes in.  There are enough people
that profits from this that us low-lifes that want spam to stop just
don't count if you want to play by the rules.

I'm all for the kneecapping proposal by citizen V.K.

--Johnny