On 2007-5-26, at 14:24, ext Pekka Savola wrote:
(Note: this is still a draft version if you're referring to
http://www.ietf.org/IESG/content/ions/drafts/ion-tsv-alt-cc.txt)
This model raises one fundamental question issue of the scope of
this document.
Who should be evaluating section 3 and 4 of this document? Is this
solely meant for ICCRG, the IETF or both? If both, would both
parties do everything described in those documents?
The basic idea behind this ION is that a researcher would bring his
or her proposal, papers and experimental data to the ICCRG, which
would then evaluate whether a proposal is safe for experimentation in
the Internet or in more restricted network environments. (According
to draft-ietf-tsvwg-cc-alt, and probably also draft-irtf-tmrg-
metrics.) That review will accompany the resulting -00 technical
specification when it is brought to the IETF.
It would be clearer if the reviewer was ICCRG, and the IETF would
not attempt to perform the same review, and the IETF wouldn't be
allowed to second-guess the proposal, e.g., that it's research has
not been done well enough if it was already positively evaluated by
ICCRG.
There is a strong expectation that the IETF would usually agree with
the review recommendation that the ICCRG made, and take on the
document. (Sufficient people overlap, the ICCRG has stronger
congestion control expertise, etc.) But process-wise it *is* up the
to the WG (likely TCPM) to come to consensus on whether they want to
adopt any given work item, and that consensus call can't be
outsourced to the ICCRG. But I would personally see it as a sign that
something went very wrong if TCPM would not publish something as
Experimental that came with a strong ICCRG review.
Lars
PS: I'm editing the ION in response to IESG comments. The latest
working version is under http://www3.tools.ietf.org/group/iesg/trac/
browser/ions/drafts - I'd be interested in hearing suggestions on how
the text could be improved.
smime.p7s
Description: S/MIME cryptographic signature
_______________________________________________
Ietf mailing list
Ietf(_at_)ietf(_dot_)org
https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/ietf