Hi,
For those who wants to have the complete session,
audio<http://singapore49.icann.org/en/schedule/mon-iana-accountability>and
transcripts<http://singapore49.icann.org/en/schedule/mon-iana-accountability/transcript-iana-accountability-24mar14-en>
are online.
BR,
Daniel
[AUDIO] http://singapore49.icann.org/en/schedule/mon-iana-accountability
[TRANSCRIPT]
http://singapore49.icann.org/en/schedule/mon-iana-accountability/transcript-iana-accountability-24mar14-en
On Tue, Mar 25, 2014 at 8:44 PM, John Curran <jcurran(_at_)istaff(_dot_)org>
wrote:
On Mar 26, 2014, at 1:12 AM, Abdussalam Baryun
<abdussalambaryun(_at_)gmail(_dot_)com>
wrote:
On Monday, March 24, 2014, IAB Chair wrote:
Today at ICANN 49 in Singapore, process to develop an Internet community
plan was launched. Since the announcement by NTA just over a week ago,
discussions have been taking place in many hallways and mail lists. Input
from the all of the community discussions needs to be gathered, and ICANN
has provided a mail list for this purpose:
ianatransition(_at_)icann(_dot_)org. An
archive is available so that everyone can see the collection of prior
postings to the list: http://mm.icann.org/pipermail/ianatransition/.
ICANN needs to encourage discussions not just make a list and think
community people will do directly.
AB -
As far as I can tell, this phase is simply an expedited call for input on
the cross-community
process and timeline that is to be used for IANA transition plan
development - specifically,
the entire community is being asked to comment on the presentation of
process and timeline
that ICANN (as the USG NTIA designated process convener) provided in
Singapore -
<
http://singapore49.icann.org/en/schedule/mon-iana-accountability/presentation-iana-accountability-24mar14-en
Amongst other things, that presentation asks the following framing
questions regarding the
IANA transition plan development process -
- What are the most important principles?
- What mechanisms are important to ensure a well-run process?
It also notes a fairly large list of ICANN, IETF, and RIR meetings
occurring between now and
September 2015, although how community discussion and cross-community
synthesis of inputs
appears to be a completely open question (and hence particularly ripe for
community input now)
The goal is to gather the input by 27 March 2014,
That is short time, I suggest icann postpones the goal date. I don't see
many inputs (only 3 or 4) on the list of icann,
It is incredibly short timeframe, but it's also important to get back
comments on the proposed
timeline and process, integrate those into a draft, and get that out for
comment by 7 April so
that it can be finalized, since it is only upon completion of all that
we'll be able to utilize the
resulting development process and have some discussions of the actual
content of the IANA
Transition Plan.
For example, if you feel that there should be just one global mailing list
for the IANA transition
plan development with continuous synthesis of all input, or one discussion
in each community
each via their processes; or that we should use one global wiki-based plan
document editing
facility, or have an appointed steering committee to synthesize inputs
between communities,
or that there should be only a few selected face-to-face meetings where we
do open forum for
cross-community integration of positions, or that we should generate
initial draft IANA transition
plan text via a random number generator, or for that matter _any_ other
process suggestions
regarding the IANA transition plan development, now is the time to get
those submitted asap...
As noted above, once ICANN integrates the received input on the
development process into a
draft document, it will go out to a formal consultation on or about 7
April, so there will definitely
be an opportunity to respond to all of the process input at that time.
That is why if you feel that
a particular process or mechanism should be used to develop the IANA
Transition plan, it is
crucial to submit it by 27 March so that the entire cross-community set of
participants will see
it in the 7 April draft process/timeline document.
(This is probably far more information about this process for input than
anyone actually wanted
to hear, but given the extremely tight timelines, I figured that is better
to write down everything
we can discern about it from being here onsite at the ICANN meeting...)
FYI,
/John
Disclaimer: My views alone. Not responsible for errors and omissions -
any resulting IANA
from this process is purely the responsibility of the
participants.
--
Daniel Migault
Orange Labs -- Security
+33 6 70 72 69 58