Ted,
On 30/01/2016 21:28, Eliot Lear wrote:
...
On 1/27/16 4:50 PM, Ted Hardie wrote:
...
Yes, and we have historically said that publishing things in
the ISE stream when they counter IETF specifications can
only be done when the IESG deems there to be no conflict
with IETF specifications.
Not so. What the community has said (in RFC 4846) is that such a conflict
is a legitimate ground for the IESG to object to publication, with the IETF
procedures around this documented in BCP 92. It is then the ISE's prerogative
to decide whether to publish or not, after reviewing the IESG's objection
and any other relevant input.
That includes, but is not limited to, input from the Editorial Board, of which
I am a member.
Brian