(LIGHTBULB)
Rereading the (previous) thread, I re-noticed Davids remark that the term "named character
references" came from the SGML world.
I was confused about it the first time as I _really_ thought that I had just read the term
(literally minutes ago) on the HTML 4 rec page and had seen use of the term in the way I intended on
mailing lists before. But I must punish myself for having misread the HTML rec on entities as it is
talking about "named character _entities_" and the users on those mailing list that used that term
wrongly should be punished for misleading me. 8|
Scrolling down the Google search result, I notice a remark about SGML named character references
being things like &#SPACE;. David, if you just would have said that the term I used was referring to
those kind of thing (by example), I wouldn't have been puzzled that much and wouldn't have had to
bother you about it.. :P
As I wanted to achieve terminology that clearly define what one means, irrespectively whether a
person is talking about SGML, XML, HTML or XHTML, I conclude this was not a good proposal. Even
though, as David more or less sais himself, the SGML term is not commenly used these days any more
and the actual confusion I caused in his mind (and would cause in mine from now on) is not likely to
occur in minds of people who are not familiar with SGML. ;)
But after this lengthy thread, there still remain (official) terms that cause
confusion as well. :-S
The actual point I tried to make is that people are using the official terms not very carefully and
what I intended with my proposal was to encourage a more explicit way of telling what you mean. So
instead of saying "entity reference", one could say "named character entity" (not "reference" ;) and
instead of "character reference", one could say "numeric character reference". It is unlikely that
people mistake the words 'named' and 'numeric', so if in future a person would start talking about
'numeric character entities', it is still clear that the person is actually talking about character
references. While if a person posts a message to this list and starts talking about "character
entities", at least a hand full of us gets confused whether he really means entities or (numeric)
character references...
Phew.. Now I can finally sleep again... ;)
By the way, I don't recall the initial poster to have clearified himself on his meaning. Though I
suspect that he meant character references as he seemed (more or less) happy with the us-ascii
solution...
Cheers,
Geert
--~------------------------------------------------------------------
XSL-List info and archive: http://www.mulberrytech.com/xsl/xsl-list
To unsubscribe, go to: http://lists.mulberrytech.com/xsl-list/
or e-mail: <mailto:xsl-list-unsubscribe(_at_)lists(_dot_)mulberrytech(_dot_)com>
--~--