fetchmail-friends
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: [fetchmail]Again: Patch for not-in-dns bug (debian bug #99197)

2001-07-01 13:27:57
Hi Eric,

on june 19th I wrote a message to this list with a patch for a bug where
fetchmail quits directly after startup if one of the servers to poll is
not in dns ("couldn't find canonical DNS name of xxx").

[...]

I'm having a design-philosophy problem with this.  When fetchmail fails, I
want it to fail noisily so the responsible persion can notice and fix the
problem.  Your change would make it fail invisibly when running in background
(which I consider the important case).

...and in the background-mode the users won't get bitten by the problem of a
temporarily failing nameserver because the code we are talking about is only
for startup (before the fork).

So I suggest

either not doing any lookups at startup in foregound-mode
or doing lookups at startup (as it is now) but disable the exit(PS_DNS) for
foreground-mode

Regards,

Gerd


<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>