ietf-822
[Top] [All Lists]

RFC-XXXX's richtext

1991-12-13 03:23:01
(Honestly, I was going to post this anyway.)

Here are some questions after reading the section on richtext in the
new draft.

- Has anyone implemented or attempted to implement text/richtext
  beyond the trivial implementation of Appendix D?  The draft doesn't
  seem to be changed much, nor have I seen much discussion of richtext
  on the mailing list, which makes me suspect that everybody is
  secretly planning to ignore this particular part of the standard...

- There seem to be two different ways to force a line break: enclosing
  text in <paragraph> </paragraph> tags or inserting <nl>.

- Has anyone consulted an SGML expert about this?  I seem to recall
  that SGML prefers to use tags with *semantic* meaning (e.g.,
  <emphasis>) rather than *lay-out* meaning such as <Bold>).

- The <ISO-10646> tag worries me.  I seem to recall that 10646 may
  come in 2-byte and 4-byte flavors.  How am I supposed to find the
  corresponding end tag?!?!?!  Or us some encoding scheme implied?
  (Also, shouldn't there be a charset=... parameter that sets the
  initial character set, instead of fixing this to be ASCII?)

--Guido van Rossum, CWI, Amsterdam <guido(_at_)cwi(_dot_)nl>
"It happens sometimes -- people just explode.  Natural causes."

<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>