ietf-822
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: gzip-8bit

2003-02-28 16:55:11
On Saturday 01 March 2003 01:00, Claus Färber wrote:
<snip>
It also includes a draft for a quoted-binary Extended CTE that allows
efficient transfer of binary data over 8BITMIME environments.
<snip>

There's a problem hiding in the claims that deflate-8bit and friends can 
be sent over 8BITMIME-supporting channels. Consider a MIA sending a 
message with deflate-8bit body to a SMTP server announcing 8BITMIME.

If the server isn't prepared to reject unknown charsets in the body of 
messages (and which server is?), it will accept the message and thus 
the responsibility for delivery.

The next hop doesn't support 8BITMIME. No problem. This is an 
intelligent server that acts by the gateway model of rfc1652 and tries 
to recode the offending body parts. Whooops... bounce. :-(

Am I missing something?

Marc

-- 
The illegal we do immediately.
The unconstitutional takes a bit longer.            -- Henry Kissinger

Attachment: pgp6zVMIVf2uG.pgp
Description: signature

<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>