Douglas Otis wrote:
Please review the recommended changes. None of the changes assume a
listing is based upon the IP address. These changes actually mitigate
this assumption regarding the use of IP addresses such as "collateral
damage" or automatic removal being a simple matter of adding back a
few more IP addresses. The error in this regard is found in the
current draft. The changes being recommended move in the direction
you suggest.
-Doug
Doug,
Ok, honest to God, I've been reading your proposals for the better part
of a week and I still have no earthly idea what your advocating, who's
using it currently, or how it's going to either make DNSBL's better, or
fight spam. Because of this confusion, I requested that several days
ago someone put together a second draft that could be approved later as
an optional enhancement to this draft so that I could review it
separately. While there's been some sort of idea bandied around, I am
not clear on what this idea is, nor on how it would be described in an
IETF draft. Would you please put something like this together so that
we can review it, rather than arguing about how wonderful it is, but in
a manner that seems to me to provide little substance? I promise I'll
read the draft as soon as it's out, just like I've read all the others.
I'll also be happy to offer comments and criticism, and if it makes
sense the AHBL will implement it, and help push it forward, but right
now I don't know what you're arguing for, I don't know whether it's even
germane to this draft, so I'm asking such that I can review a clearly
worded definition of what you want, please draft it.
Andrew
AHBL.org
_______________________________________________
Asrg mailing list
Asrg(_at_)ietf(_dot_)org
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/asrg