ietf-clear
[Top] [All Lists]

[ietf-clear] CSV in action

2004-10-09 07:07:05
Mark <admin(_at_)asarian-host(_dot_)net> wrote:

I am noy clear about the reputation services, though. Are any of them
even existent?

   I'm not aware of any reputation services which attempt to report
on all domains which publish CSV SRV records. (There are periodic
discussions whether such services are in-scope for discussion here:
stay tuned...)

   There are definitely accreditation services which report on domain
names (as opposed to IP addresses). Any of these could easily report
in the DNA TXT format, if they don't already.

   Personally, I'm not pushing for publication of any of this stuff,
except on an experimental basis, until we get the CSV spec through
last-call. (In my experience, _only_ a last-call will actually bring
out the suggestions for changes...)

And is there even a point publishing CSV records without the reputation
service PTR?

   Absolutely. See the FAQ.

(If I read things correctly, you could skip the publicatuon of the PTR).

   Correct. Publishing PTR is chiefly intended for [re]establishing a
good reputation if you find people not trusting your SRV authorization.

--
John Leslie <john(_at_)jlc(_dot_)net>