ietf-mailsig
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: Comparison Matrix on proposals

2004-10-10 23:05:11

At 11:29 PM 10/9/2004 -0700, william(at)elan.net wrote:


I'm working on a comparison matrix for proposals presented at MASS bof:
http://www.elan.net/~william/emailsecurity/emailsignatures-comparisonmatrix.htm

Current problem there is that I'm not greatly familiar with TEOS so I'd 
like some help in feeling last column. For other proposals if I got 
anything wrong please let me know and also suggest any new raws for 
comparing different features of proposals.

This is really useful; thanks.

Only adjustments I'd make on IIM (based on the -00 draft) are that I wouldn't 
call what we have a "key server" since it doesn't serve keys.  I'd say, 
perhaps, that we have HTTP-based key authorization.b

I will try to get you updates when the -01 draft comes out.

One nitpick:  the three rows that read "Signature is not effected" should read 
"Signature is not affected".

You might also want a row giving pointers to each proposal, or at least saying 
whether they have been described in Internet Drafts.  I consider that to be a 
fairly important distinguishing characteristic as well.

-Jim


<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>