Re: Sieve Extension I-Ds(not) becoming RFCs and IANA assignments (e.g.

Is this a good place to post a sieve script that is failing or would 
that be too implementation-specific?  I'm trying to learn Sieve, coming 
from a Procmail background, and using websieve as a user interface.  I 
have a few scripts which seem to simply not execute, and it seems to be 
related to what WebSieve calls "Continue processing rules".  It is 
running on a Cyrus IMAP server
Thanks,
Matt

Matthew Elvey wrote:

> On 4/29/04 8:08 PM, Matthew Elvey (FM) sent forth electrons to convey:
>
> > Wow, things have been quiet on this list.
> > Anyone considering implementing draft-elvey-refuse-sieve-01.txt?
>
> :(
>
> > I just noticed draft-daboo-sieve-spamtest-01.txt became an RFC:
> > http://www.faqs.org/rfcs/rfc3685.html - good, because the draft had 
> > expired, and someone wants to reference it in another doc not as a 
> > work-in-progress.
> > I guess the Sieve homepage at cyrussoft is sorely out of date (I 
> > emailed the maintainer (sieve%cyrusoft.com 
> > <mailto:sieve(_at_)cyrusoft(_dot_)com>) a while back and didn't hear back - see 
> > below.)
>
> Cyrus/CyruSoft has updated their sieve page considerably - looks good 
> now.
> > http://www.iana.org/assignments/sieve-extensions is presumably an 
> > up-to-date listing of SIEVE extensions that have reached RFC status.
> > RFC 3598 is the subaddress extension,
> > RFC 3431 is the relational test,
> >
> > There aren't IANA assignments for the extensions vacation, regex, or 
> > imapflags.
> > Are their authors interested in progressing them to RFC status or 
> > getting IANA assignments?  If I don't hear back, I'll take this up.
>
> I created a page to track what Sieve implementations support what 
> extensions here:
> http://wiki.fastmail.fm/wiki/index.php/SieveExtensionsSupportMatrix.  
> Edits, links welcome (DIY-Do It Yourself; it's a wiki).
> > Any comments before I email iana%iana.org with the RFC # for 
> > spamtest, and a reservation for "refuse"?
>
> Emailed.
>
> > On 4/14/2004 9:41 PM, Matthew Elvey sent forth electrons to 
> > sieve%cyrusoft.com to convey:
> > > Hi.  I was wondering if you'd add a list of links to sieve 
> > > extensions.  None are officially beyond the I-D stage yet [wrong], 
> > > but they are often at the <multiple implementations exist> stage.  
> > > If you'd like to, e.g. link to 
> > > http://www.cyrusoft.com/sieve/#implementations, I'll put up a page 
> > > there.
> > > Hope you guys push Sieve along in the standardization process too, 
> > > or if you're not doing that, make changes to improve it, like the 
> > > one I suggest in my I-D for the 'refuse' extension.
> No comment?
>
> notes:
>
> vacation, per
>
> draft-showalter-sieve-vacation-05.txt
>
>
>  imapflags - I-D still valid, but IANA section is missing.