ietf-mxcomp
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: Differences between CSV and Sender-ID

2004-06-30 09:44:13

In <C8DECEE0-CAA1-11D8-A606-000A95B3BA44(_at_)hxr(_dot_)us> Andrew Newton 
<andy(_at_)hxr(_dot_)us> writes:

Therefore, I'd like to get feedback from others:
    Do you appreciate the difference between a HELO check vs. a
    MAILFROM/PRA/SUBMITTER check?

Yes.

    Do you understand the semantic differences between a CSV check on
    HELO and an SPF/Sender-ID check on HELO?

I don't think there is a significant semantic difference.

    Is it clear to you that CSV has definite security advantages over
    SPF/Sender-ID?

No


I'm only asking these questions so that we can hopefully refine the
conversation on this topic.

Thanks, I think these questions are useful.


-wayne