ietf-mxcomp
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: IPR Disclosure for Sender-ID

2004-08-03 09:38:23

I find it difficult to imagine the licensing terms to be reasonable for
most.  See:

http://download.microsoft.com/download/6/0/a/60a02573-3c00-4ee1-856b-afa39c020a95/callerid_license.pdf


An alternative with the _same_ feature set can be found as follows:

1) Authenticate and verify the authorization of the EHLO domain with CSV.

2) To restrict the RFC 2822 From domain, list all acceptable EHLO domains
for From domain allowed in a MARID TXT record.

Call the <From:EHLO> (Mailer-ID) and the TXT record the MARID Channel
permissions (MCP).


This would allow authentication to happen without adding a single DNS
lookup.  Unlike Sender-ID with DNS timeouts that fail to implement
exponentional back-off while making huge demands upon DNS, or where the
duration of their query may otherwise take hours.  By using only names,
the delegation problems are removed.  A simple wildcard used in this
permitted list could encompass the required scope.  There would not be
CIDR block lists that allows easy abuse.

All the advantages, none of the disadvantages...

-Doug