ietf-mxcomp
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: Another question on draft-ietf-marid-submitter-02

2004-08-04 10:27:48

On Wed, Aug 04, 2004 at 10:05:31AM -0700, Hadmut Danisch wrote:
| 
| e.g. the message is sent with
| 
| MAIL FROM: <aaa(_at_)aaa(_dot_)aaa> SUBMITTER=bbb(_at_)bbb(_dot_)bbb
| 
| then bounce messages etc. are sent to aaa(_at_)aaa(_dot_)aaa, isn't it?
| 
| Is that what it is supposed to be?
| 

yes, that is correct.

if SUBMITTER is provided, you do an SPF query against it;
only a PASS result is acceptable; if you get anything else,
you reject.

if SUBMITTER is not provided, you fall back to the MAIL FROM
value; if you get a FAIL result, you reject.  You do the
fallback because you expect that the sender is in fact
SUBMITTER aware but because the PRA == MAIL-FROM the sender
chooses to reduce
  MAIL FROM:<K> SUBMITTER=<K>
to just
  MAIL FROM:<K>.

SUBMITTER was considered superior to SRS because it was
expected to be easier for forwarders.