ietf-openpgp
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: Identifying revoked certificates

2001-09-06 14:45:00

At 5:06 PM -0400 9/6/01, Michael Young wrote:

 Although the current packet ordering rules don't address certificate
 revocation, I'd suggest that a prudent ordering would put each after
 its target.  This would an even stronger hint.  I note that neither
 PGP6.5 nor GnuPG produces this ordering.  At first glance, it appears
 that they use order of arrival.  [Just the same, would anyone object
 to suggesting this ordering in section 10?]


Yes. A change to the standard that requires all the implementations to
change is not desirable. I don't see what good it does for them other than,
"You'll thank me for this later." Telling them how to write their programs
adds complexity, and complexity lessens security.

        Jon