ietf-smime
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: Signed Label (was RE: 'Signature Purpose' attribute?)

1998-03-31 16:22:47
Tim Dean wrote:

2. I am somewhat doubtful that access control in the recipient's user agent 
is going to add a jot of Real
Security in practice.  It would surely be extremely unwise to place any kind 
of reliance on it.  Any
Computer Scientist worth his salt is quickly going to figure how to by-pass 
this check and read
everything which arrives in his computer.  (And he is probably the kind of 
person you didn't want to
unintentionally send a message to anyway!)


This is certainly true.  I too wonder about the value of rules-based access 
control in a off-the-shelf product.  I suspect that the realities of commercial 
implementations would make it difficult to establish any trust in recipient 
RBAC processing.

Chris