ietf
[Top] [All Lists]

RE: A charter for the IESG

2003-03-07 18:53:08
Harald,

-----Original Message-----
From: ext Harald Tveit Alvestrand [mailto:harald(_at_)alvestrand(_dot_)no]
Subject: A charter for the IESG

Some discussion has taken place on the POISED list 
(poised(_at_)lists(_dot_)tislabs(_dot_)com), but the point has been made that 
for such a 
potentially important document, the IETF list may actually be a more 
appropriate venue for discussion. Hence this note.

Could you point to the archive of this list? At least the pointer in the 
'Poisson' WG (concluded) 
(http://www.ietf.org/html.charters/OLD/poisson-charter.html) does not seem to 
be valid. It would be rather interesting to see what has been discussed.

This IESG charter attempts to capture what the IESG has 
believed that it 
has been asked to do by the IETF community. Most of the 
document is simply 
collecting references to sections of other IETF BCP documents, and 
attempting to form a coherent picture of what the IESG is 
supposed to be 
doing. I do not believe that it shows the IESG to be much 
different from 
what the community currently believes it is.

Is this view of the IESG share by the whole IESG? What I mean is if you have 
discussed this within the IESG already?


What I hope to do with this document is:

- Discuss it on this mailing list and on the POISED mailing 
list as the 
community finds appropriate

I am not sure what would be the right 'process'. However, at least I personally 
would find it better to have the discussion in a discussion list that is also 
officially alive, and has a current archive. This makes it easier for everybody 
to follow/contribute to the discussion.

Cheers,

Jonne.



<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>