ietf
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: Nomcom 2010-2011: READ THIS: Important Information on OpenDisclosure

2010-09-22 22:24:33
Ummm, no.


So would you even make public the comments that people send in?

IMHO we have not agree to this (and I wouldn't support it).

Ross

Here's the new text from RFC 5680 (and it's all additions, no deletions or changes) at the end of the three paragraphs in [RFC3777], Section 3, "General", bullet 6, which are currently:

     All deliberations and supporting information that relates to
     specific nominees, candidates, and confirmed candidates are
     confidential.

     The nominating committee and confirming body members will be
     exposed to confidential information as a result of their
     deliberations, their interactions with those they consult, and
     from those who provide requested supporting information.  All
     members and all other participants are expected to handle this
     information in a manner consistent with its sensitivity.

     It is consistent with this rule for current nominating committee
     members who have served on prior nominating committees to advise
     the current committee on deliberations and results of the prior
     committee, as necessary and appropriate.

  add the following paragraphs:

     The list of nominees willing to be considered for positions under
     review in the current NomCom cycle is not confidential.  The
     NomCom may disclose a list of names of nominees who are willing to
     be considered for positions under review to the community, in
     order to obtain feedback from the community on these nominees.

     The list of nominees disclosed for a specific position should
     contain only the names of nominees who are willing to be
     considered for the position under review.

     The NomCom may choose not to include some names in the disclosed
     list, at their discretion.

     The NomCom may disclose an updated list, at their discretion.  For
     example, the NomCom might disclose an updated list if the NomCom
     identifies errors/omissions in a previously disclosed version of
     the disclosed list, or if the NomCom finds it necessary to call
     for additional nominees, and these nominees indicate a willingness
     to be considered before the NomCom has completed its
     deliberations.

     Nominees may choose to ask people to provide feedback to the
     NomCom, but should not encourage any public statements of support.
     NomComs should consider nominee-encouraged lobbying and
     campaigning to be unacceptable behavior.

     IETF community members are encouraged to provide feedback on
     nominees to the NomCom, but should not post statements of support/
non-support for nominees in any public forum.
_______________________________________________
Ietf mailing list
Ietf(_at_)ietf(_dot_)org
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/ietf