ietf
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: Gender diversity in engineering

2012-05-04 04:21:30
NSF has a ton of information on this for the U.S. population.  I'm too lazy 
right now to dig it up, but it is there.

On May 1, 2012, at 4:40 PM, James M. Polk wrote:

There have been some good numbers floated on recent threads, but at least for 
me, they aren't enough to gain a complete (or nearly complete) picture of the 
issue.

Having studied statistics, we need to know a starting point, and look for the 
reductions (or increases) from that point forward. Starting in high school is 
not sufficiently refined enough, as there are a lot that take advanced math 
(personally I'd start with trig - because that kicked my ass - but rarely is 
it its own class, so let's start with calculus 1) that don't go into 
engineering. Thus, high school is probably not a good place to measure from. 
Therefore, it needs to be college.

We need to know

% of class (based on year started) that is female in engineering
  (do we want to start with electrical and CS to
   be more applicable to our situation?)

We'll call that percent 'X'

then

%X of drops from engineering (BS) (or just elec/CS?) over the college years 
before graduation?

then

%X that enter workforce after BS in Engineering (or just elec/CS?) into the 
engineering field?

then

%X that start graduate school (MS) in engineering (or just elec/CS)?

%X that receive MS degree in engineering (or just elec/CS)?

%X that enter workforce after MS in Engineering (or just elec/CS?) into the 
engineering field?

then

%X that start doctoral school (PhD.) in engineering (or just elec/CS)?

%X that achieve PhD. in engineering (or just elec/CS)?

then

%X that enter workforce after PhD in Engineering (or just elec/CS?) into the 
engineering field?

This will likely track those that are entering the engineering workforce, and 
with what level of education. From that point in the analysis - we can 
attempt to track at what point there are further drops out of the engineering 
workforce by women (i.e., after how many years). Or is it as simple as 
problems after childbirth to reenter the workforce (for whatever reason).

As an example, if there is a significant difference from those that drop out 
after their BS from those that drop out MS, then maybe something should be 
done to encourage women to stay for the MS.

comments or questions?

James