ietf
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: https at ietf.org

2013-11-07 20:02:04
Pranesh Prakash wrote:

Dave Cridland [2013-11-06 06:39]:

Requiring HTTPS, particularly with reasonable cipher suites,
might restrict use of from certain jurisdictions.

Could we have more concrete examples, please?

A significant number of IETF documents (including BCP 78)
contain this statement:

   Distribution of this memo is unlimited.

_Restricting_ access to such documents on the www.ietf.org/tools.ietf.org
to HTTPS only seems to be incompatible with this fundamental principle.

Like prohibiting to put RFC on open bookshelves in public libraries
because other folks could see you taking it out of the shelve.

-Martin

<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>