Hello Ray,
Here are my comments:
Substantial:
Please add something about URI stability, i.e. that the Revamp should
not change existing URIs. Some CMSes have the weird tendency to replace
any and all URIs with long sequences of letters and numbers. It would
e.g. be a pity if http://www.ietf.org/about/note-well.html would no
longer exist, and instead the same text would be at
http://www.ietf.org/ABCDEF1234567890 or so, because that will break many
links.
7.d.vii: "For pages that require the use of applets, a link to the page
where the user can obtain the plug-ins will be provided.": Do we really
want/need to go that far? What about just saying "no use of
applets/plugins"?
Editorial:
4. Process: "input from by groups" -> "input from groups" (or "input by
groups")
7. c Navigation: I'd suggest "add/edit/delete/reorder" rather than
"add/edit/delete/sort"
7.d.vii: "Pages with forms that require a timed response": maybe better
"timely response"?
7.f.i: "Administrator: administers the site and configuration,
edits/deletes and publishes content all high level functions.":
Something seems to be amiss near "content all".
Regards, Martin.
On 2014/03/12 03:41, IETF Administrative Director wrote:
The IETF Administrative Oversight Committee (IAOC) desires community input on a
Statement of
Work (SOW) for redesigning the public-facing IETF website (www.ietf.org) before
pursuing a Request
for Proposals (RFP).
Goals for the project include:
· Modernizing the website style,
. Making the website work better for all classes of devices,
· Incorporating current best-practices in website design and
implementation, and
· Improving content maintenance processes.
The redesign aims to improve how the website works for IETF participants,
support new and
potential IETF participants in becoming successful active contributors, and
better inform
other interested individuals about the work of the IETF. Usability testing and
other forms of input
from key audiences, including current IETF participants, will guide the
project. The broader IETF
community will be kept informed as the project progresses.
The complete draft Statement of Work is available at:
http://iaoc.ietf.org/documents/IETF-Website-SOW-20140205.pdf
The IAOC appreciates any input from the community and will consider all input
received by 25 March.
All information submitted in response to this announcement is voluntary and may
be used in the
development of the SOW.
Thanks for your continuing advice and support.
Ray Pelletier
IETF Administrative Director