[Top] [All Lists]

Re: [nmh-workers] I Could Have Sworn that the inc Command used to work.

2019-06-09 03:43:07

Hi Bakul,

Regardless of whether it's a good idea, since the kernel is using
effective user and group IDs for testing permissions, if a user ID
is used to determine what files to access then it should be the
effective one rather than the real one.  Do you agree?

I haven't thought about this to be frank because IMHO privilege
escalation should be used very very sparingly.  My instinct would be
to use euid/egid *only* in programs that *are* to be used
setuid/setgid. So that a misuse will be caught more quickly.

Using real-UID does the wrong thing and that *hopefully* shows up due to
nmh spotting the problem and the error rippling all the way up to the
eyeballs.  But it might not and the problem needs to be spotted and then
hunted.  Using effective-UID does the right thing AFAICS because now nmh
is matching the kernel's efforts.

Cheers, Ralph.


<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>